Welcome to The Mayor of Old Town
The Mayor of Old Town, located in Fort Collins, CO, is a culinary gem that expertly marries a world-class beer selection with delectable cuisine. With 99 draft beers, including elusive finds like Pliny the Elder, it caters to beer aficionados and casual drinkers alike. The menu features inventive dishes, from savory tacos to unique veggie burgers, ensuring everyone finds satisfaction. Patrons rave about the outstanding service and the inviting atmosphere that feels fresh and different from typical breweries. Whether indulging in truffle fries or the signature schnitzel sandwich, your taste buds will be tantalized, making this venue a must-visit spot in Old Town.
-
632 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80524, United States Hotline: +1 970-682-2410
Welcome to The Mayor of Old Town, a delightful culinary oasis nestled in the heart of Fort Collins, Colorado. Located at 632 S Mason St, this restaurant stands out not just for its exquisite fare but also for its impressive selection of beverages—boasting an astounding 99 beers on tap, including rare finds like Pliny the Elder. This commitment to quality beer sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.
Upon entering The Mayor of Old Town, you are greeted by a welcoming ambiance that contrasted the typical industrial vibe found in many breweries. The décor resonates with a unique charm that enhances your dining journey. As one customer put it, the layout is refreshingly distinct, inviting patrons to sit back and savor their meals.
The menu is a celebration of flavor and creativity. Guests rave about the food, praising everything from the glorious fish tacos and tasty tacos to the delicious vegetarian options like the various veggie burgers that cater to a diverse clientele. The flavors are well-balanced and expertly crafted, ensuring each dish is a triumph of culinary mastery. Many customers have highlighted the PTO fries and renowned Buffalo cauliflower as must-tries, alongside creative sides that elevate traditional pub grub.
When it comes to service, The Mayor of Old Town truly shines. Reviews consistently point to the knowledgeable and friendly staff, who are genuinely passionate about their offerings. The attentive service contributes to an experience that makes you feel valued and cared for while exploring an impressive array of brews and dishes.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a more leisurely evening with friends, The Mayor of Old Town promises something for everyone—a blend of exceptional food, an extensive beer selection, and an atmosphere that's both comfortable and inviting. If you’re in Fort Collins, make it a point to visit this hidden gem. It will undeniably leave you craving more.
For reservations and inquiries, feel free to reach out at +1 970-682-2410. Get ready for a dining experience that might just make The Mayor of Old Town your new favorite spot!
A happy find as we were doing a one night layover in Fort Collins after a long day of driving. A world-class selection of draft beers that carefully balanced all styles of beer. As an East coaster, I was so pleased to find Pliny the Elder on tap since it's practically unobtainable. The food was outstanding as well, and we appreciated that there were some smaller plate options. Really appreciated that our server was knowledgeable about the beers, as that's becoming rare for the staff to know the specifics of the beers, even in places that position themselves as beer destinations. The decor and layout of the space were refreshingly different than the brutalist concrete and steel design of .most breweries.
The food is incredibly delicious, well flavored and perfectly cooked. Very pleased with their cleanliness and upkeep of the establishment. Super wide brew selection and good wine options. Highly recommended to anyone with taste buds
I went once there for my second dinner in Fort Collins as I was visiting. The first evening I went to a much-talked-about European food cafe which had a whopping one vegetarian option - pasta. The food was also quite American, but that never bothers me. I didn't know what to expect at The Mayor of Old Town, but there I was, being offered three different choices of delicious veggie burgers. The service was fantastic, the waitress extra kind and patient. They were even able to find me a low percentage alcohol, very light beer. I will make it a point to go there when I visit next. Thank you!
Great service and tasty tacos. 99 beers on tap.
We went to this place because of the reviews online, and it did not disappoint! They have a wide beer selection and the food is amazing. Everything we ordered on the menu for a party of 9 was fantastic. Check this place out if you are in the area and you won't be disappointed.
The Mayor of Old Town surpassed all expectations during my recent visit. It was my first time dining here so we tried an array of dishes. Keep in mind it was dimly lit so these pictures don’t do the food justice, but WOW! Each dish was bursting with flavor! We indulged on fish tacos, nachos, PTO fries, cauliflower, and a jalapeno cream cheese pretzel. I highly recommend them all. And I can’t forget to mention the impeccable service provided by Corrie, our server. The combination of outstanding service, mouthwatering cuisine, and amazing selection of beers on tap makes The Mayor of Old Town well deserving of this five-star review. I can't believe I hadn't discovered this gem sooner, and am eagerly looking forward to returning and exploring more of their menu options.
I used to love grabbing a burger at the Mayor when I lived in Fort Collins. I’m glad that the quality has remained the same during my recent visit. The free pretzel with a pint during happy hour is a great deal to check out. Another favorite dish I would recommend is the Buffalo cauliflower.
A dated-looking venue with poor parking options, but definitely worth the effort to get in and try their food and beer options! An incredible selection of over 80 beers on tap, focused on Colorado breweries, but complemented by some excellent out of state choices. The food is not just your typical pub grub. They've elevated some classic dishes with amazing sauces and flavors. Don't miss the truffle fries and the schnitzel sandwich with habanero jelly, slaw.